Evangelicals: Keep Your Emphasis, But Resist Reductionism

|

I am an evangelical. Despite all the baggage with that term and the failures of the movement it represents, I am still an evangelical (and a passionate one at that). I understand why some have dropped the label, but what it represents historically and means to me personally is so dear that I’m willing to fight for it.

When defining the term “evangelical,” most go straight to Bebbington’s quadrilateral, but I prefer to start with evangelicalism’s beating heart: You must be born again and have a personal relationship with Jesus Christ. Evangelicals like me have a burden for people who have been baptized, joined the church, share the Lord’s Supper, and drop a check in the offering plate each week, but are not “alive to God” (Rom. 6:11). They don’t have the life of God in their soul. They don’t have the “vital piety” of which the Wesleys spoke.

John Wesley, a lifelong Anglican priest, looked around at his own beloved Church and saw people “having the appearance of godliness, but denying its power” (2 Tim. 3:5). He preached a message of forgiveness of sins that was deeply personal: “Justifying faith implies, not only a Divine evidence or conviction that God was in Christ reconciling the world unto Himself, but a sure trust and confidence that Christ died for my sins, that He loved me and gave Himself for me” (Sermon 5). Each person must see the cross as something for them, they must personally trust in Christ, and they must have the Holy Spirit come to dwell in their heart, raising them to new life in Christ. That’s the evangelical emphasis, and I say “Amen!”

From Emphasis to Reductionism

The evangelical emphasis on new birth and vital piety is good and right. But it’s crucial to distinguish between emphasis and reductionism. Emphasis is keeping a main thing a main thing (I say “a” main thing because we can emphasize more than one thing). Reductionism is pitting a main thing against all the other things. Fred Sanders uses the illustration of a knife which needs both heavy steel and a sharp cutting edge. Emphasis is having a sharp cutting edge. Reductionism is separating the cutting edge from the heavy steel behind it, rendering it useless.

If we use classic Christianity as our guide—including what the early evangelicals taught and believed—then the “heavy steel” is the Church with its historic doctrines, practices, and God-ordained role in our salvation. Evangelicalism was a reaction against churches that had these historic doctrines and practices but had lost their sharp, cutting edge. Initially, evangelicals sharpened the edge. But over time, evangelicals have become so fixated on the sharp edge that they have chipped away at the heavy steel until little is left, and many evangelical churches are far removed from historic Christian norms.

Many evangelical churches are far removed from historic Christian norms.

Some are so far removed from the heavy steel that they now actively undermine or even despise it. I’ll never forget sitting in an evangelical “revival” service when a preacher proclaimed at the top of his lungs, “At the end of the day, I don’t really care if you get baptized! I don’t really care if you join a church! What really matters is whether or not you are born again!” This is emphasis-devolved-into-reductionism in a nutshell. It goes beyond emphasizing something good to downplaying something else that is vitally important. Most evangelicals are not as bold as the preacher that I heard, but in practice many function the same way. They do call people to baptism, but only as an afterthought, sometimes years after their conversion, usually without catechesis, and then only as a “public profession of faith” that’s “just a symbol” and “doesn’t save”—all claims which are foreign to the early evangelicals and to historic Christianity.

Three Examples

One of the most influential figures in the early evangelical movement was John Wesley, and as a Wesleyan evangelical, I’m especially indebted to him as a spiritual forefather. I don’t agree with everything that Wesley ever said or did, nor do I think that modern evangelicals need to mindlessly conform themselves to him or any other historical figure. But when comparing modern evangelicalism to early evangelicalism, he’s a helpful reference point. Let’s consider three examples.

First, the early evangelicals had a very high view of Creeds, catechisms, and the obligation of the Church as a pillar of truth to catechize every believer in the whole counsel of God. Wesley affirmed the Creeds and especially loved catechisms, slightly adapted the Westminster Shorter Catechism for his people’s use, wrote his own children’s catechism, and instructed every Methodist elder to spend two hours each week catechizing children. Wesley never viewed catechisms as a threat to evangelical purposes. On the contrary, he treated them as wood on the fire of a heart alive to God.

Many modern evangelicals, however, disdain catechisms or don’t even know what they are. I once introduced catechisms to a group of evangelicals, and an older man told me afterwards, “All my life I heard that catechisms were ‘bad’ and a Roman Catholic thing, but now I see that they are actually good.” Another man told me, “In 30+ years of attending evangelical churches, I’ve never even heard the word ‘catechism’ used.” Evangelicals saw catechized people who were spiritually dead and threw out the baby with the bathwater.

Second, the early evangelicals had a very high view of the sacraments. The first Methodist denomination stated that one of its two reasons for existing was to administer the sacraments. Wesley believed that baptism was a means of saving grace. In fact, he believed that it was an ordinary means by which God forgives sins and causes people to be born again. He was also a strong advocate for what he called “constant communion” (the imprecise word “frequent” frustrated him). Wesley instructed every Methodist elder to administer communion every single Sunday, though Wesley himself preferred daily Eucharist and communed almost every day of his life. Again, Wesley never viewed this as a threat to evangelical purposes. On the contrary, he believed that Christ was really present in the Supper, and that it was the believer’s spiritual food—something which everyone who was alive to God should long for!

Many modern evangelicals, however, are suspicious of the very word “sacrament.” The main thing that most want to say about baptism is that it doesn’t save. I once heard a preacher claim that if you think baptism saves, you aren’t an evangelical (the early evangelicals would like a word!). Many still use the historic language of “an outward sign of an inward work,” but have no idea what it originally meant, and reduce it to mean “a symbol of something that God has already done.” Many have the Lord’s Supper once or twice a year and deny Christ’s real presence there. When administering the bread and cup, they change Christ’s own words of institution to say, “This represents Christ’s body/blood.” It’s now increasingly common to have people pick up a prepackaged two-in-one bread and wine combo in the vestibule on their way in, and give communion to themselves in their seat. How did we get here?

Third, the early evangelicals had a very high view of the Church’s role in salvation. John Wesley taught that in the office of the keys (Mt. 16:19; 18:17–18; Jn. 20:23), the Church has been given “a power of declaring with authority the Christian terms of pardon; whose sins are remitted and whose retained … and a power of inflicting and remitting ecclesiastical censures; that is, of excluding from, and re-admitting into, a Christian congregation” (Notes on the Bible, John 20:23). Because the Church has been given this authority by Christ, church membership is an obligation for everyone who claims to be a Christian: “Every follower of Christ is obliged, by the very nature of the Christian institution, to be a member of some particular congregation” (Sermon 39, “Catholic Spirit”). And to be clear, “member” does not mean someone who starts attending a church and decides “this is my church now.” It is the action of the Church, exercising the office of the keys to admit people into (or exclude them from) the body. Wesley merely taught what all Protestants and all Christians for centuries had taught (see Belgic Confession, Article 38 on “The Obligations of Church Members”).

Modern evangelicals, however, view church membership as entirely optional. Some treat it as a club for extra-devoted Christians. Others treat it as something that’s handed out to anyone who regularly attends, without any vetting or accountability, rendering it meaningless. Others still have stopped having membership altogether. Because more fundamentally, they see no role for the Church in our salvation. Salvation is viewed as an entirely individualistic matter that’s “between you and God.” They can’t even begin to conceive of why Martin Luther, father of the Protestant Reformation and defender of justification by faith alone, would ask every person that he discipled, “Where does God forgive you your sins?” and teach them to answer, “In the Christian Church God forgives me and all other believers all our sins” (Small Catechism, 245). How can we be so far removed from our own evangelical and Protestant history?

These examples can be grouped together under the heading of “religion,” the dreaded enemy of the average evangelical. Evangelicals have gone beyond warning against the wrong kind of religion to claiming that “Christianity is not a religion, it’s a relationship.” As I’ve explained elsewhere, this modern mantra is deeply unbiblical and foreign to historic Christianity. We should not even claim to have a relationship with Jesus while undermining, downplaying, or outright rejecting the religion and religious beliefs, practices, and structures which Jesus himself commanded and ordained. We need a sharp cutting edge and the heavy steel behind it.

People Feel It

I can’t speak for all evangelicals, but I have met many serious Christians who feel the consequences of evangelical reductionism. Many evangelicals are alive to God, but they are starving for more because they have been deprived of classic Christianity. As a pastor friend once said, “We are great at getting people saved, but we have no idea what to do with them afterwards!” The result of relationship without religion is rootlessness and restlessness. My wife and I even know a surprising number of evangelicals who have become Eastern Orthodox in the last five years. Others are becoming Roman Catholic.

Many evangelicals are alive to God, but they are starving for more because they have been deprived of classic Christianity.

Most evangelicals will never go that far, but in the articles that have been published on this phenomenon, the conclusion is usually the same: people are hungry for stability and deeper spiritual formation. They want to belong to something bigger than themselves. They’re curious about the church calendar and rhythms that can more deeply form their families with the story of the gospel. They want to learn about the saints. They want to be catechized. They want to understand why they believe what they believe—and they want to know that what they believe is what Christians have always believed! 

In my conversations with restless evangelicals, I’ve urged them: Don’t jump the pond. Many of the early evangelicals understood your concerns much better than most do today. Classical Protestantism has what you’re looking for, and I believe it’s more biblical and faithful to historic Christianity. Explore your own history and look for a church in your area that is at least wrestling with these issues.

Where We Go From Here

When I think of what we need in evangelicalism today, the word “reformation” comes to mind. But that is ultimately a pneumatological word. It’s something that Spirit brings about. We can’t bring about reformation any more than we can bring about revival. But as the Spirit works in our hearts and lives, and gives us a burden for the church, we can lead change where we’re at and offer up our gifts to the broader people of God. If you’re a church leader, here are a few suggestions for how you can play your part.

1. Don’t shy away from strong evangelical preaching on the new birth and a personal relationship with God. We’re always in danger of swinging the pendulum too far in the other direction. Our emphasis needs to be preserved. Carry a burden for church members who do not show evidence of regeneration, and warn from the pulpit that “unless one is born again he cannot see the kingdom of God” (Jn. 3:3). You can do this without undermining other vital beliefs and practices that are taught in Scripture and ordained of Christ for our good.

2. Re-catechize your church. Regularly say the Creeds, the Ten Commandments, and the Lord’s Prayer (the original “catechism”), and then find a catechism that expounds them. A catechism class is ideal, but sometimes it’s hard to get existing members to sign up. Get creative if you need to. Teach a Sunday School series or read catechism Q&As in public worship and preach a series of catechetical sermons. In The Whole Counsel of God catechism, we give significant attention to the issues discussed in this article (see especially Chapter 4), synthesizing the Protestant consensus. The Global Methodist Church also has a short catechism on Christian Life and Doctrine. The Anglican Church of North America has To Be A Christian. Find a catechism that works for you or adapt one to meet your needs. Once your church is catechized, make it a standard expectation for all potential members/baptism candidates to go through a catechism class or catechumenate.

3. Slowly and patiently deepen your worship. The great Methodist ecumenist Thomas Oden emphasized that classic Christianity lives out of a history of consensual ecumenical worship. In an interview, Oden said,

Evangelical and charismatic communities are moving toward several decades of recovery of the liturgical life that they have been so deeply missing, a retrieval of the liturgical tradition that Wesley took for granted, the religion of the Prayer Book, and the apostolic tradition as recollected during the earliest Christian centuries of persecution. These communities will be profoundly reformed by classical liturgies, returning to mode of worship that were far more available in the third century than the twentieth.

This “return” doesn’t happen overnight, so be patient, pick your battles, and always lead with much teaching. Help people to see the value in the changes that you want to make. There are countless resources out there to help you. The 2019 Book of Common Prayer is a treasure, and I’m encouraged that the recent Draft Liturgies of the Global Methodist Church are returning to the Prayer Book tradition.

4. Most difficult of all, recover the Church as a clearly defined, visible institution with authority by recovering a biblical practice of the sacraments, membership, and discipline. Most evangelical reductionism has its roots in a diminished ecclesiology. Evangelicals must reclaim the Church’s role in salvation. As Luther, Calvin, Turretin, Hooker, and the other Protestant reformers taught, echoing Augustine, Cyprian, and the Church before them, God has ordained the Church to be our spiritual Mother and an Ark of salvation (see David Fry’s article “What is the Church’s Role in Our Salvation?”). God alone saved Noah, but he chose the ark as the vessel in which Noah needed to be in order to be saved. God alone provides the milk of his Word, but he has ordained for the Church to be the Mother whose breasts channel this milk to his people. Evangelicals need to understand that two things are true at the same time: (1) being baptized and joining the church doesn’t automatically save them or guarantee their final salvation, and (2) those who want to be saved must (at least ordinarily) have the Church as their Mother.

Buy this author a coffee

Holy Joys is a not-for-profit, volunteer ministry. Our authors write because they love the church. If you appreciate this author's work, please consider showing your support.

Johnathan Arnold
Johnathan Arnold
Johnathan is a husband and father, pastor of Redeemer Wesleyan Church, global trainer with Shepherds Global Classroom, and founder of holyjoys.org. He is the author of The Kids' Catechism and The Whole Counsel of God: A Protestant Catechism and Discipleship Handbook (forthcoming). Johnathan has also been published in Firebrand Magazine, the Arminian Magazine, God’s Revivalist, and the Bible Methodist Magazine.